homarr/PHASE2-FINDINGS.md

Phase 2 — where the memory actually goes

Measured with scripts/benchmarks/stress-restore.mts on a populated instance, not an empty one: a real backup (4 boards, 51 widgets, 11 integrations) restored through the onboarding restore UI, signed in, then the busiest board (28 items / 16 widget kinds, 28/28 widgets reaching data-homarr-widget-ready) opened, reloaded 4×, and soaked idle.

Images built locally from known commits so the comparison is not against a stale registry tag: baseline = merge-base 06724cfeb, branch = abec79abe.

Metric choice

memory.current moved between 192 and 261 MiB for the same baseline image across runs, because cgroup v2 counts reclaimable page cache. At idle that split was 144 MiB anon vs 77 MiB page cache. Everything below therefore reports anonymous memory, which was stable to ±2.5 MiB across repeated runs of the same image.

Aggregate: branch vs merge-base

stage	baseline	branch	delta
boot idle	139.2 / 144.1	115.2 / 99.0	−24%
board loaded (28 widgets)	255.2 / 260.4	228.1 / 230.2	−11%
after 4 board reloads	401.4 / 384.0	358.8 / 362.6	−8%
image size	410 MB	388 MB	−5%

Attribution — this is the part that matters

Built cumulatively from the baseline image, one change at a time:

config	boot idle anon	verdict
baseline	139.2	—
+ integrations barrel diet	139.5	no idle effect
+ Redis clients 6 → 2	139.3	no idle effect
+ serverExternalPackages: mysql2, pg	118.6	−21 MiB — the entire idle win
branch (everything)	115.2 / 99.0	no further gain beyond the above

change	diff size	idle	under load
serverExternalPackages + mysql2/pg	1 line	−21 MiB	−25 MiB
integrations barrel diet	~10 files, +119 lines	~0	−40 MiB (±25 noise)
Redis clients 6 → 2	4 files	~0	~0
V8 heap cap (HOMARR_MAX_OLD_SPACE_SIZE=512)	1 line	~0	~0
cache invalidation + next-cache-handler	~30 files, 66 call sites, ~290 lines	0	0

Why one config line beats the whole module-graph refactor

packages/core/src/infrastructure/db/drivers/index.ts statically imports all three drivers, so mysql2 and pg are in the graph even when DB_DRIVER=better-sqlite3. Bundled, their full transitive graphs are inlined into the boot-loaded server chunks; marked external they become a require() that the sqlite path never reaches. Verified inside the images:

image	server chunks	mysql2 in node_modules
baseline	108,336 KB	no — it was inlined into the chunks
+ external pkgs	94,936 KB	yes — traced, loaded only on demand
branch	98,084 KB	yes

This is fix-catalog F6 ("load only the configured DB driver") achieved by one config line, after the dynamic-import() attempt was reverted for breaking Vitest.

The V8 heap cap is a safety ceiling, not a reduction

branch-cap4096 (cap effectively removed) matched branch at every stage — idle 99.0 vs 115.2, board loaded 230.2 vs 228.1, after stress 362.6 vs 358.8. The workload never approaches a 512 MB old space, so the cap cannot reduce steady-state usage. It is still worth keeping as one line: baseline's soak hit a 543.8 MiB anon sample, and capped baseline topped out at 347.5 MiB, which is exactly the unbounded-drift protection issue #5301 needs. It should not be described as a memory saving.

The cache layer is provably dead code

On the current branch state there are 0 "use cache" directives, 0 cacheTag(), 0 cacheLife(), 0 unstable_cache, and no tagged fetch in application source — and cacheHandlers/cacheComponents have both been removed from next.config.ts. packages/next-cache-handler is referenced only by a package.json dependency line; nothing imports it. The 66 remaining invalidate* call sites call revalidateTag on tags nothing ever registers, with no handler to receive them, inside a try/catch that swallows the resulting out-of-scope error. Zero functional effect, ~30 files of churn.

Verification after trimming

The three zero-effect changes were removed (next-cache-handler, cache-tags/ cache-invalidation and its 66 call sites, Redis 6 → 2 — keeping the pubSub:last:* TTL). Re-measured to confirm nothing regressed:

stage	baseline	branch before trim	after trim
boot idle	139.2 / 144.1	115.2 / 99.0	120.0
board loaded	255.2 / 260.4	228.1 / 230.2	229.5
after 4 reloads	401.4 / 384.0	358.8 / 362.6	357.0
peak	684.8 / 710	679.8 / 673	599.5
image	410 MB	388 MB	388 MB

Identical within run-to-run noise at every stage, lowest peak of any config, and 28/28 widgets rendered — so −883 lines and −18 files cost nothing. Diff against the merge-base went from 100 files / 3,336 insertions to 82 files / 2,484.

Round 2 — GC tuning and wider unbundling

Re-run on the second backup, where the demo account is already an admin whose home board is the 28-item board, so the harness modifies nothing (fixture changes: none). Every run now also proves the session instead of inferring it (see below) and records CPU seconds plus board-load latency, because every remaining lever trades memory for CPU.

config	idle	board loaded	under load	peak	CPU s	median load
round-1 result	120.0	209.6	353.9	710.6	15.8	594 ms
--max-semi-space-size=2	97.1	183.5	340.5	581.6	17.3	598 ms
--max-semi-space-size=4	97.2	183.0	306.6	560.2	17.1	570 ms
+ wider serverExternalPackages	90.3	164.6	302.5	594.2	16.3	549 ms

--max-old-space-size only bounds the old generation. V8 sizes the young generation generously too (16 MB per semi-space by default) and that slack is resident memory. Bounding it to 4 MB is the single biggest remaining win: −19% idle, −21% peak. It is not free — GC runs more often, costing ~8% CPU (15.8 → 17.1 CPU-seconds) — but board-load latency did not regress. 2 MB was not better than 4 MB and cost slightly more CPU.

Externalising the remaining server-only packages (winston, drizzle-orm, ical.js, jszip, ldapts, node-unifi, @kubernetes/client-node, linkedom) took another −18 MiB at board-loaded with slightly lower CPU and latency. The cost is image size: 388 → 401 MB, since those packages now ship in node_modules rather than being tree-shaken into chunks. Worth it here — RAM is the constrained resource on a self-hosted box — but it is a real trade, not a free win.

Cumulative vs merge-base: idle 141.7 → 90.3 MiB (−36%), board loaded 257.8 → 164.6 MiB (−36%), under load 392.7 → 302.5 MiB (−23%).

Final A/B, with repetitions

Everything above is one sample per configuration, which is fine for ranking changes but not for a headline. This is the merge-base image against the PR's end state, alternated, on the same backup — 2 runs before, 3 after:

run	idle	board loaded	under load	after soak	peak
before #1	144.2	249.0	392.8	529.6	753.0
before #2	142.3	268.2	385.1	538.5	626.1
after #1	100.5	176.8	311.1	204.3	590.9
after #2	91.1	163.5	319.9	212.7	568.0
after #3	90.3	164.6	302.5	206.4	594.2

metric	before (mean)	after (mean)	change
boot idle	143.3	94.0	−34%
board loaded	258.6	168.3	−35%
under load	389.0	311.2	−20%
after idle soak	534.1	207.8	−61%
peak	689.6	584.4	−15%

The two groups do not overlap on any stage. The before-side idle samples land within 1.9 MiB of each other, which is what justifies treating a ~50 MiB gap as real rather than noise. Earlier single-sample rounds suggested −36%; the repeated figure is −34%, and that is the number used in the PR.

Round 3 — tried, and reported as not a memory win

@scalar/api-reference-react (a docs SPA behind one admin tab) moved to next/dynamic with ssr: false, and @modelcontextprotocol/sdk to serverExternalPackages.

metric	previous build	with round 3
idle	90.3 / 91.1 / 100.5	89.4
board loaded	163.5 / 164.6 / 176.8	161.5
peak	568.0 / 590.9 / 594.2	563.9
image	401 MB	398 MB
CPU s	17.0	17.5

Every memory figure lands inside the previous build's spread. At the better end of it, but inside — so on one sample this is not a demonstrated reduction and is not counted in the headline. Kept anyway for the deterministic −3 MB image and because a documentation SPA should not be compiled for an SSR pass that discards its output.

Recording it here rather than quietly folding it into the total: the whole point of the harness is to stop plausible-sounding changes from being credited with wins they did not produce.

Measured but not pursued

lever	measured cost	why not pursued
in-image Redis (F12)	8.1 MiB RSS (6.3 PSS)	The catalog estimated 10–40 MB; the real figure is 8. Removing it means replacing the pub/sub bus for single-instance — real risk for ~5% of the footprint.
in-image nginx (F13)	9.2 MiB RSS (3.1 PSS)	Two processes, but PSS is 3 MiB. It terminates TLS and proxies; not worth the deployment change at this size.
locale subset (F19)	~12 MB image	Reduces languages a user can pick — a product decision, not an optimisation, and it does not move RAM.

next-server is 225.8 MiB RSS of the ~236 MiB total at board-loaded, so process-level trimming has little left to give. Further wins have to come out of that one heap.

Is the measurement actually behind a login?

Worth stating explicitly, because "28 widgets rendered" would be meaningless if the board were public. Each run now asserts all three:

1. access fixture changes: none — the harness modified nothing in the restored data.
2. control: anonymous access to /boards/default denied (landed on /auth/login) — a cookie-less context cannot render the board, so it is genuinely permission-gated.
3. signed in as demo (session cookie "homarr.session-token" present) — Auth.js issued a session; leaving /auth/login alone is not accepted as proof.

Earlier rounds were correct but only inferred this from the private board rendering; the assertions now fail the run instead of quietly measuring an anonymous page.

Round 4 — the client, which the container numbers never showed

A real session reached ~880 MB server and a 650 MB browser heap. The harness had been measuring one tab on one board with no interaction, so it saw none of this.

What the 650 MB actually is

From the captured .heapsnapshot (4M nodes, 18.2M edges):

• 71,596 live React Fibers (~35k components). Identified structurally, not by name: the retainer edges are alternate, return, child and __reactFiber$….
• ~7,900 SVG element fibers (charts and icons), 1,726 <td>, ~88k event listeners.
• Retained heap is only 181 MiB against a 650 MB peak. Snapshots are taken after a forced GC, so the rest is transient allocation churn from re-rendering — not retention. The trace agrees: 71,850 UpdateLayer events, 41 s in v8.callFunction.

So the client cost is render volume and re-render churn. Tuning gcTime would not have touched it.

The most-mounted component

@mantine/core/Box (513 of 3,918 fibers on a 28-widget board). It is Mantine's universal primitive — every Mantine component renders through it — so it is a symptom of how many components are mounted, not a bug in itself. Matching proportions (13% here, 17% in the 650 MB snapshot) make it near-certain that the minified y in that snapshot is Box.

The genuinely suspicious finding was 71 Menu → Popover → PopoverDropdown triplets mounted on a board that shows 28 widgets. A controlled experiment using the existing enableRightClickOnWidgets user flag isolates the cost:

board state	fibers
per-item context menus on	3,918
per-item context menus off	3,554

364 fibers, 9%, for menus that are almost never opened — and it scales with item count. The dropdown contents are already lazy; the Menu/Popover/PopoverDropdown wrappers are not.

The fix: one board-level menu (shipped)

WidgetContextMenuProvider mounts a single menu for the whole board, anchored to the cursor. Items keep only a contextmenu/long-press listener. The dropdown takes the section's gridstack ref as a prop, because the shared menu lives outside any SectionContext — reading it from context there crashed the board.

Verified with scripts/benchmarks/verify-context-menu.mts, run against both builds:

	per-item menus	shared menu
menu opens on right-click	PASS	PASS
menu shows actions	PASS (5)	PASS (5)
Escape closes it	PASS	PASS
re-opens on a second widget	PASS	PASS
idle fibers	18,670	16,278 (−12.8%)
fibers added by using the menu	+4,191	+4

Memory, two runs each, four tabs across two boards:

metric	per-item (mean)	shared (mean)	change
JS event listeners	10,128	7,774	−23%
DOM nodes	9,189	8,287	−10%
browser JS heap	54.1 MiB	52.7 MiB	−2.5%
median board load	520 ms	479 ms	faster
container CPU	20.4 s	20.0 s	unchanged

Server memory is unchanged, as expected for a client-only change. One after-stress sample read 362 MiB against ~267 for its pair and for both controls — GC timing on a single sample, not a regression.

The listener reduction is the one that matters most: the 650 MB session had ~88k listeners, and this removes a per-widget source of them.

Two earlier attempts, and a broken test

A first attempt deferred each item's Menu until the first right-click. It was reverted after the gate failed it — but that verdict was wrong: the gate used Playwright's click({ button: "right" }), which does not emit a contextmenu event here, so it failed shipped code identically. The "fiber explosion" attributed to that change showed up on the control too.

The gate now dispatches a real contextmenu event and is validated by passing against unmodified code first. Any optimisation gate that has never been run against the un-optimised build is not evidence — it can only tell you something changed, not that it still works.

A measurement flaw worth recording

The demo account in the backup had completed_board_tour = 0, so every run before this round was measuring the first-time-user path with the onboarding tour mounted. Completing the tour changed the tree by only 38 fibers, so the earlier numbers stand — but the harness was not measuring steady state, and that was luck rather than design.

Server side

A server heap snapshot pulled from a live container: 37 of 70 MiB is strings (71,287 of them), consistent with the memoised translation payload. Unexplored.

Recommendation

Keep — carries the measured win:

1. --max-semi-space-size=4 — 1 line, the biggest single lever (−19% idle, −21% peak)
2. serverExternalPackages — the DB drivers alone were −21 MiB idle; the wider set another −18 MiB at board-loaded, at +13 MB image
3. integrations barrel diet — the under-load win
4. V8 heap cap — 1 line, bounds the pathological drift (label it as a ceiling)
5. jsdom → linkedom — image size + a genuine XSS hardening; a jsdom import costs ~136 MiB RSS whenever the SVG path is hit
6. dead /api/about routes + runtime package.json glob removal

Drop — measured at zero, and it is most of the diff:

1. packages/next-cache-handler (~290 lines, orphaned)
2. cache-invalidation.ts, cache-tags.ts and all 66 call sites across ~30 routers
3. Redis 6 → 2 consolidation is defensible hygiene but bought nothing measurable — low priority, not worth the churn on its own

Dropping 1 and 2 removes the bulk of the file churn while keeping 100% of the measured memory improvement.

Reproducing

STRESS_IMAGE=homarr-bench:branch \
STRESS_BACKUP_ZIP=~/Downloads/your-backup.zip \
node --experimental-strip-types scripts/benchmarks/stress-restore.mts

The backup is read from that path and never copied into the repo — it contains real integration secrets and the instance's encryption key.